Distant Early Warning: Coupland on McLuhan

January 25th, 2011 | Category: Reviews, Videos

If I had to pick a patron saint, a hero, or a single intellectual influence for my adult self, it would undoubtedly be Marshall McLuhan. If you’ve spent any time at all reading my work, you’ve seen his name and his ideas. Marshall McLuhan: You Know Nothing of My Work! (Atlas & Co., 2010) is the latest biography of the man and differs from previous versions in many ways, not the least of which is the author. Having struggled through several of Douglas Coupland’s novels, I had my reservations about his writing this book. I am glad to say he eloquently quelled most of my concerns.

The world weighs on my shoulders
But what am I to do?
You sometimes drive me crazy
But I worry about you — Rush, “Distant Early Warning”

There are several things that people often overlook or misunderstand about McLuhan that Coupland nailed in this book. One was his devout Catholic faith, which rooted his thinking in many ways once he found it, and another was his deep disdain of the media and its attendant technology. In spite of his insight, foresight, and prescience, he hated this stuff. Coupland points out many times that McLuhan wouldn’t have liked our current reliance on technology and connectivity one bit, but he would’ve found it interesting. Another of Coupland’s key insights is that, above all else, McLuhan was an artist, “one who happened to use ideas and words as others might use paint” (p. 16). Seen in this way, a lot of his work might make a hell of a lot more sense to newbies, critics, and haters alike. Like the best artists, he was a pattern perceiver of the highest order.

There’s really no considering this book, its author, or its subject without considering Canada. Yes, Canada, The Great White Wasteland that brought us Rush, hockey, Bob and Doug McKenzie, Justin Bieber, Coupland and McLuhan, as well as the latter’s most obvious forebear, Harold Innis. It’s cold up there, folks — cold and spread out. It makes one appreciate the human element.

“Call it religion or call it optimism,” Coupland writes, “but hope, for Marshall, lay in the fact that humans are social creatures first, and that our ability to express intelligence and build civilizations stems from our inherent social needs as individuals” (p. 165). Or, as McLuhan himself put it, “The user is the content” (Take that, so-called “social media experts”). McLuhan’s consistent focus on the individual is what has kept his ideas fresh in the face of new contrivances.

I know it makes no difference
To what you’re going through
But I see the tip of the iceberg
And I worry about you — Rush, “Distant Early Warning”

My problem with Coupland’s past work has had less to do with his writing ability (he’s an excellent writer) and more to do with his appropriation of Salingerisms, and not even a biography could escape. Coupland alludes to Catcher in the Rye by comparing McLuhan to Holden Caulfield on page 111. It’s an apt comparison, and it characterizes The Mechanical Bride-era McLuhan accurately, but I have to admit being irked at the reference.

With all of that said, You Know Nothing of My Work made me proud (I fancy myself something of a McLuhan scholar, so this is meant as a heartfelt compliment), and it made me cry (Though I already knew the story of McLuhan’s last days, a word-man unable to use words is still one of the saddest things I can imagine). I’d like to think Marshall McLuhan would’ve liked this book. It’s treats him with respect, humility, and humor, and I think it “gets” him. What else could he want from a biography?

————

Here is a scene that illustrates the heights of McLuhan’s fame, what Coupland calls “every geek’s dream,” and this book’s namesake: Marshall Mcluhan in Woddy Allen’s Annie Hall (1977) [runtime: 2:43]:

Further Posting:

12 Comments »

  • Tweets that mention Distant Early Warning: Coupland on McLuhan | Roy Christopher -- Topsy.com said:

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Roy Christopher, diane bluegreen. diane bluegreen said: RT @RoyChristopher: "You know nothing of my work!" Douglas Coupland on Marshall McLuhan: http://royc.org/?p=4224 […]

  • McLuhan the Younger: Two New Books | Roy Christopher said:

    […] have been plenty of people touted to carry the mantle left behind by Marshall McLuhan — Neil Postman, Douglas Rushkoff, Paul Levinson, even Jean Baudrillard, but no one has been […]

  • For the Nerds: Bricks, Blocks, Bots, and Books | Roy Christopher said:

    […] are covered inside, as well as the LEGO font, image-to-brick conversions, home brick-printing, Douglas Coupland, brick artists, record-setting builds, and robots — Mindstorms, LEGO’s programmable […]

  • 2011: Are You Going to Eat That? | Roy Christopher said:

    […] and Uploading by Peter Lunenfeld (The MIT Press), The Beach Beneath the Street by Ken Wark (Verso), Marshall McLuhan: You Know Nothing of My Work! by Douglas Coupland (Atlas & Co.). Most Overrated: Ready Player One by Ernest Cline […]

  • Mark Dery: Nothing’s Shocking | Roy Christopher said:

    […] of it. Each essay was what McLuhan would call a probe—a nomadic rover, wound up and let loose on the terrain of a media event, a […]

  • Mindfulness and the Medium | Roy Christopher said:

    […] the “advent of newer media alters the meaning and relevance of the older. Media overlap, or, as Marshall McLuhan has put it, move through one another as do galaxies of stars, each maintaining its own basic […]

  • Tales Rabbits Tell | Roy Christopher said:

    […] virtual rabbits to software, citing everyone from Eugene Thacker, McKenzie Wark, William Gibson, Marshall McLuhan, and N. Katherine Hayles, to Slavoj Žižek, Deleuze and Guattari, Vilém Flusser, and Giorgio […]

  • Ill Communication | Roy Christopher said:

    […] of scrutiny as well. Genosko also uses Baudrillard to critique other communication theory, from McLuhan and Marx to Deleuze and Guattari. “For Baudrillard,” he writes, […]

  • Beyond the Body with Rosi Braidotti | Roy Christopher said:

    […] furthermore that when “you are on the phone or on the air you have no body” (p. xxix), Marshall McLuhan (1962) dismembered the body. Our media might be extensions of ourselves, but they’re also […]

  • h+ Magazine | Covering technological, scientific, and cultural trends that are changing human beings in fundamental ways. said:

    […] and furthermore that when “you are on the phone or on the air you have no body” (p. xxix), Marshall McLuhan (1962) dismembered the body. Our media might be extensions of ourselves, but they’re also […]

  • Harriss Bisby said:

    Hey! Nice review. Out of curiosity, what would you say Marshall Mcluhan’s feelings about print and books were? From most of the interviews with him that I’ve read, I get the feeling that they were negative. So, what do you think his feelings were, and do you (clearly a highly literate person) agree with him?

  • Roy Christopher (author) said:

    Well, McLuhan was a literary man. He hated the “new” media. So, though he didn’t much like writing, I think he was well into books.

    Me? I dig all of it. I’m always interested to see what we come up with next.

    Thanks for your comment.